I agree with Jasenka and Dahlia. The first image with the deeper, more saturated colors is more appealing to me. Yes you can see some detail in the bottom of the 2nd image but for me personally it doesn’t add any interest to the shot. But I’m a big fan of silhouettes so others may disagree. 🙂 I’d also get rid of the speck in the upper right. And is the ghosting on purpose?