Up on the roof

  • This topic has 16 replies, 10 voices, and was last updated 5y ago by Rob Eyers.
Viewing 11 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #478069
      Lenny Wollitz
      Participant
        • Allows Edits: Yes
        • Posts:3131
        @el-dub
        • Contender Icon
        Allows Edits? Yes

        Is this too plain?  A new paint job made this place look real fresh, so… It is on the top of a 4 story building and I would like to show the scale of it. I was thinking of adding clouds but I like the simplicity of the shot and all the negative space.  It is the from the camera colors but did increase the saturation but did not change the hue and cropped it.

        1,000 sec., f5.6, 72mm, iso100

        In about 3 weeks I should be fully vaccinated and will start doing street photography again after almost 18 months of isolation. I feel like I’m about to explode!

      • #478111
        Greg
        Participant
          • https://www.flickr.com/photos/greghaab/
          • Allows Edits: Yes
          • Posts:683
          @glegg
          • Member’s Pick Icon
          Allows Edits? Yes

          Not too plain for me. I’m still trying to figure out what that thing is. 🙂

          Seriously, the image really grabs my eye as is.

          • #478169
            Lenny Wollitz
            Participant
              • Allows Edits: Yes
              • Posts:3131
              @el-dub
              • Contender Icon
              Allows Edits? Yes

              Greg, We see 10 or so of these in other colors on an eccentric neighbors roof and didn’t have any idea what they are until we toured Gaudi’s eccentric house in Madrid and saw ventilators there  that look similar so we think they are Mexican style non-functional knock-offs.

          • #478154
            beth
            Participant
              • https://www.instagram.com/naught.figs/
              • Allows Edits: No
              • Posts:3427
              @loki
              • Photo of the Week Winner Icon
              • Contender Icon
              Allows Edits? No

              maybe add a little more contrast, but i like it.

            • #478170
              Lenny Wollitz
              Participant
                • Allows Edits: Yes
                • Posts:3131
                @el-dub
                • Contender Icon
                Allows Edits? Yes

                Thank you Beth.  I’m usually told I use too much contrast 😉

                • #478249
                  beth
                  Participant
                    • https://www.instagram.com/naught.figs/
                    • Allows Edits: No
                    • Posts:3427
                    @loki
                    • Photo of the Week Winner Icon
                    • Contender Icon
                    Allows Edits? No

                    well they lied to you.  i’ve always liked your style.  be yourself and add contrast.

                • #478177
                  Peter Nowak
                  Participant
                    • http://www.instagram.com/petr.nowak
                    • Allows Edits: Yes
                    • Posts:1064
                    @peternowak
                    • Contender Icon
                    • Socialite Icon
                    Allows Edits? Yes

                    Great !!! I like this type of images. Definitely not too plain. This type of images should look plain and more abstract then real. I like colors. Nothing to change I think.

                  • #478180
                    Tersha
                    Keymaster
                      • https://www.flickr.com/photos/diane_rose/
                      • Allows Edits: Yes
                      • Posts:19185
                      @tersha
                      • Photo of the Week Winner Icon
                      • Mobile Maestro Icon
                      • Contender Icon
                      • Member’s Pick Icon
                      • Throwdowner Icon
                      Allows Edits? Yes

                      Hi Lenny, I can’t see anything to change, I like it as is!

                    • #478203
                      bucweeet
                      Participant
                        • Allows Edits: Yes
                        • Posts:2454
                        @paul-3
                        • Contender Icon
                        Allows Edits? Yes

                        Not sure if my monitor’s dirty or not, but there appears to be a couple of white spots/dots in the bottom LH corner of the blue square by the brown.

                        Nice image Lenny!

                        • #478213
                          Patrick
                          Participant
                            • Allows Edits: Yes
                            • Posts:14448
                            @patrickw-2
                            • Photo of the Week Winner Icon
                            • Contender Icon
                            • Member’s Pick Icon
                            • Throwdowner Icon
                            Allows Edits? Yes

                            Love the shapes and colors Lenny , nice seeing on your part .. I personally think the image would be so much stronger if the ornament on the roof was not there i feel it interrupts the balance a little.

                            Stay well and good luck getting out of isolation and back shooting 🙂

                            Your monitor is clean Paul i see the white spots here as well.

                        • #478223
                          Rob Eyers
                          Participant
                            • Allows Edits: Yes
                            • Posts:6240
                            @reyers
                            • Mobile Maestro Icon
                            • Contender Icon
                            • Member’s Pick Icon
                            Allows Edits? Yes

                            Art is art Lenny so I have nothing to add on that front. I do think that some of the edits could be improved. I’ve outlined the areas. There’s a variety of hard line edits that could be cloned to match the softer real lines, some white and dark spots to be removed, and areas were the blue could be extended with the edge softened. Pixel peeping I know but worth the attention if your committed to this image.

                          • #478302
                            Dahlia Ambrose
                            Keymaster
                              • https://www.instagram.com/livingsta/
                              • https://www.flickr.com/photos/livingsta/
                              • Allows Edits: Yes
                              • Posts:12162
                              @dahliaambrose
                              • Photo of the Week Winner Icon
                              • Mobile Maestro Icon
                              • Member’s Pick Icon
                              • Throwdowner Icon
                              Allows Edits? Yes

                              Love it as it is Lenny. Great colours and frame. I agree with Rob’s comments about some edits in the image 🙂

                            • #478362
                              Lenny Wollitz
                              Participant
                                • Allows Edits: Yes
                                • Posts:3131
                                @el-dub
                                • Contender Icon
                                Allows Edits? Yes

                                Hey people, thanks for the comments!

                                Rob, I was aware of the edits that needed to be done but am a lazy editor.  I have someone that wants a use this shot so I guess I will have to get off my lazy you-know-what and fix it up.  Gracias señior pixel miron!

                                • #478368
                                  Rob Eyers
                                  Participant
                                    • Allows Edits: Yes
                                    • Posts:6240
                                    @reyers
                                    • Mobile Maestro Icon
                                    • Contender Icon
                                    • Member’s Pick Icon
                                    Allows Edits? Yes

                                    De nada amigo y por favor no me llames “senior” LOL

                                • #478726
                                  Falxy
                                  Participant
                                    • Allows Edits: No
                                    • Posts:1438
                                    @falxy

                                    No Achievements Yet!

                                    Allows Edits? No

                                    Lenny absolutely hits the spot………..best image in ages in this forum….good work!! 🙂

                                  • #478791
                                    Lenny Wollitz
                                    Participant
                                      • Allows Edits: Yes
                                      • Posts:3131
                                      @el-dub
                                      • Contender Icon
                                      Allows Edits? Yes

                                      Duncan, Thank you very much!

                                      Rob, here is the cleaned up one for printing.

                                      • #478792
                                        Rob Eyers
                                        Participant
                                          • Allows Edits: Yes
                                          • Posts:6240
                                          @reyers
                                          • Mobile Maestro Icon
                                          • Contender Icon
                                          • Member’s Pick Icon
                                          Allows Edits? Yes

                                          Much better IMHO Lenny. Anything left to do is extremely minor.

                                          EDIT: The transitions between the colours are very hard. Maybe try selecting those edges and try applying a very small Gaussian blur to see if you like that better. To me it takes away the hard edge look of being edited. Not trying to be picky… just another point of view 🙂

                                           

                                    Viewing 11 reply threads
                                    • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

                                    About Author