Matte vs glossy?

Viewing 26 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #43904
      Mitchell Tomlinson
      Participant
        • Allows Edits:
        • Posts:36
        @mitchellfoto

        No Achievements Yet!

        So, the eternal question remains.

      • #57082
        Rob Wood (Admin)
        Keymaster
          • https://instagram.com/lightstalking
          • https://www.flickr.com/photos/lightstalking
          • Allows Edits: Yes
          • Posts:16097
          @admin-2
          • Photo of the Week Winner Icon
          • Mobile Maestro Icon
          • Contender Icon
          • Socialite Icon
          Allows Edits? Yes

          lol – I gotta admit, in general, I like matte – especially for black and white photography, but it really depends on the situation.

          Matte would probably not look so great for most macro shots for example.

        • #78896
          Rob Wood (Admin)
          Keymaster
            • https://instagram.com/lightstalking
            • https://www.flickr.com/photos/lightstalking
            • Allows Edits: Yes
            • Posts:16097
            @admin-2
            • Photo of the Week Winner Icon
            • Mobile Maestro Icon
            • Contender Icon
            • Socialite Icon
            Allows Edits? Yes

            lol – I gotta admit, in general, I like matte – especially for black and white photography, but it really depends on the situation.

            Matte would probably not look so great for most macro shots for example.

          • #57083
            David Haworth
            Participant
              • Allows Edits:
              • Posts:155
              @sunseeker

              No Achievements Yet!

              Glossy for glossy images…. SLK Mercedes for example πŸ™‚
              Some of my impact B/w requires Glossy. But some of my best work looks fab on a quality matte rag paper.
              David

            • #78897
              David Haworth
              Participant
                • Allows Edits:
                • Posts:155
                @sunseeker

                No Achievements Yet!

                Glossy for glossy images…. SLK Mercedes for example πŸ™‚
                Some of my impact B/w requires Glossy. But some of my best work looks fab on a quality matte rag paper.
                David

              • #57084
                John McGarity
                Participant
                  • Allows Edits:
                  • Posts:195
                  @macgerahty

                  No Achievements Yet!

                  I prefer matte, personally, but I agree that it really does depend on the image. I actually really like a nice lustre print, too. A little bit of the best of both worlds. A nice textured finish like matte, and really good color saturation like a glossy.

                • #78898
                  John McGarity
                  Participant
                    • Allows Edits:
                    • Posts:195
                    @macgerahty

                    No Achievements Yet!

                    I prefer matte, personally, but I agree that it really does depend on the image. I actually really like a nice lustre print, too. A little bit of the best of both worlds. A nice textured finish like matte, and really good color saturation like a glossy.

                  • #57085
                    Abe
                    Participant
                      • Allows Edits:
                      • Posts:21
                      @zeusatolympus

                      No Achievements Yet!

                      Thoughts on printing! It can the toughest part of photography at least for me! Using the camera or computer is pretty easy in comparison! When something goes wrong most of the time it can be figured out easily. Printing is doable but not so easy.
                      I do a little of my own printing. I don’t have the space nor do I want the investment in the better printer I would want. It is just not worth it.
                      I have been through several printing services! Local and online!
                      The local guys were not very likable and didn’t seem to care if they got my business! It was mostly about attitude and they did me a favor because I looked elsewhere and found better prices and printing.
                      I tried shutter fly! There service is fairly good because every tine there was a problem they were all over it! The printing in mediocre at best and they tease you with deals that always have a short deadline so you never get a chance to use them.
                      I settled on SmugMug. They are great for so many reasons and have come through for me every time! Down load the printer profile and you will get pretty close to what you envisioned for your image. I did some test prints from Smug Mug, luster. matte. glossy. and metallic, plus what I have ordered. They were great!
                      That being said….
                      Each image has it own needs! Making the choice of which finish is a matter of taste, framing, glass treatment, where it’s going to be placed, etc. I have done prints that I wondered if I would change to another finish next time. A few! So! Matte or Glossy? Luster works as the default finish, but have realized that it’s better to be bold in your choices for print! You were bold when you took the shot. Why stop at the printing?

                    • #78899
                      Abe
                      Participant
                        • Allows Edits:
                        • Posts:21
                        @zeusatolympus

                        No Achievements Yet!

                        Thoughts on printing! It can the toughest part of photography at least for me! Using the camera or computer is pretty easy in comparison! When something goes wrong most of the time it can be figured out easily. Printing is doable but not so easy.
                        I do a little of my own printing. I don’t have the space nor do I want the investment in the better printer I would want. It is just not worth it.
                        I have been through several printing services! Local and online!
                        The local guys were not very likable and didn’t seem to care if they got my business! It was mostly about attitude and they did me a favor because I looked elsewhere and found better prices and printing.
                        I tried shutter fly! There service is fairly good because every tine there was a problem they were all over it! The printing in mediocre at best and they tease you with deals that always have a short deadline so you never get a chance to use them.
                        I settled on SmugMug. They are great for so many reasons and have come through for me every time! Down load the printer profile and you will get pretty close to what you envisioned for your image. I did some test prints from Smug Mug, luster. matte. glossy. and metallic, plus what I have ordered. They were great!
                        That being said….
                        Each image has it own needs! Making the choice of which finish is a matter of taste, framing, glass treatment, where it’s going to be placed, etc. I have done prints that I wondered if I would change to another finish next time. A few! So! Matte or Glossy? Luster works as the default finish, but have realized that it’s better to be bold in your choices for print! You were bold when you took the shot. Why stop at the printing?

                      • #57086
                        Lisa
                        Participant
                          • Allows Edits:
                          • Posts:27
                          @lmboulden

                          No Achievements Yet!

                          I am partial to matte. I love the texture of it. I have to agree with others though that it does depend on the photo.

                        • #78900
                          Lisa
                          Participant
                            • Allows Edits:
                            • Posts:27
                            @lmboulden

                            No Achievements Yet!

                            I am partial to matte. I love the texture of it. I have to agree with others though that it does depend on the photo.

                          • #57087
                            Susan David
                            Participant
                              • Allows Edits:
                              • Posts:279
                              @susandavid

                              No Achievements Yet!

                              Just to mess things up a little, I’m a semi gloss kinda gal. However, I do like some of the textured papers out there, esp Hahnemuhle paper. The picture feels so good (and looks good too!).

                            • #78901
                              Susan David
                              Participant
                                • Allows Edits:
                                • Posts:279
                                @susandavid

                                No Achievements Yet!

                                Just to mess things up a little, I’m a semi gloss kinda gal. However, I do like some of the textured papers out there, esp Hahnemuhle paper. The picture feels so good (and looks good too!).

                              • #57088
                                tom dinning
                                Blocked
                                  • Allows Edits: No
                                  • Posts:3675
                                  @tomdinning

                                  No Achievements Yet!

                                  Allows Edits? No

                                  a fence sitter, susandavid.
                                  I know a few people who print onto art paper. If I can ever break into Christines strong room where she does her water colours I’ll give it a try. Keep you informed

                                • #78902
                                  tom dinning
                                  Blocked
                                    • Allows Edits: No
                                    • Posts:3675
                                    @tomdinning

                                    No Achievements Yet!

                                    Allows Edits? No

                                    a fence sitter, susandavid.
                                    I know a few people who print onto art paper. If I can ever break into Christines strong room where she does her water colours I’ll give it a try. Keep you informed

                                  • #57089
                                    David Haworth
                                    Participant
                                      • Allows Edits:
                                      • Posts:155
                                      @sunseeker

                                      No Achievements Yet!

                                      Semigloss Susandavid? Isn’t that like having your cake and eating it too? πŸ™‚ Soft black and white images need soft matte paper. Bold BLACK and WHITE images.. now will they look good on matte? maybe semi gloss… now Canon or Nikon??? Hmmm?

                                    • #78903
                                      David Haworth
                                      Participant
                                        • Allows Edits:
                                        • Posts:155
                                        @sunseeker

                                        No Achievements Yet!

                                        Semigloss Susandavid? Isn’t that like having your cake and eating it too? πŸ™‚ Soft black and white images need soft matte paper. Bold BLACK and WHITE images.. now will they look good on matte? maybe semi gloss… now Canon or Nikon??? Hmmm?

                                      • #57090
                                        Susan David
                                        Participant
                                          • Allows Edits:
                                          • Posts:279
                                          @susandavid

                                          No Achievements Yet!

                                          Yup that me a fence sitter. I do admit the glossy is exceptional for some prints but it’s the damn fingermarks I keep leaving behind that makes me stay away from it. I’m so bad at that. I really do like the textured mattes a LOT for my black and whites. But semi-gloss works good for all the ones going under glass. I like it…i’ve used it for years..and I’m happy πŸ™‚

                                          P.S. Nikon rules πŸ™‚

                                        • #78904
                                          Susan David
                                          Participant
                                            • Allows Edits:
                                            • Posts:279
                                            @susandavid

                                            No Achievements Yet!

                                            Yup that me a fence sitter. I do admit the glossy is exceptional for some prints but it’s the damn fingermarks I keep leaving behind that makes me stay away from it. I’m so bad at that. I really do like the textured mattes a LOT for my black and whites. But semi-gloss works good for all the ones going under glass. I like it…i’ve used it for years..and I’m happy πŸ™‚

                                            P.S. Nikon rules πŸ™‚

                                          • #57091
                                            Rob Wood (Admin)
                                            Keymaster
                                              • https://instagram.com/lightstalking
                                              • https://www.flickr.com/photos/lightstalking
                                              • Allows Edits: Yes
                                              • Posts:16097
                                              @admin-2
                                              • Photo of the Week Winner Icon
                                              • Mobile Maestro Icon
                                              • Contender Icon
                                              • Socialite Icon
                                              Allows Edits? Yes

                                              Oh, that’s the forum’s first throw down! I was wondering how long it would be. πŸ˜‰

                                            • #78905
                                              Rob Wood (Admin)
                                              Keymaster
                                                • https://instagram.com/lightstalking
                                                • https://www.flickr.com/photos/lightstalking
                                                • Allows Edits: Yes
                                                • Posts:16097
                                                @admin-2
                                                • Photo of the Week Winner Icon
                                                • Mobile Maestro Icon
                                                • Contender Icon
                                                • Socialite Icon
                                                Allows Edits? Yes

                                                Oh, that’s the forum’s first throw down! I was wondering how long it would be. πŸ˜‰

                                              • #57092
                                                Susan David
                                                Participant
                                                  • Allows Edits:
                                                  • Posts:279
                                                  @susandavid

                                                  No Achievements Yet!

                                                  @admin LOL Someone had to finally do it. When I’m teaching my group meetings I like to stress that it’s not about the camera or the paper you use it’s the individual behind the camera that takes the photograph that’s important. The camera, paper, etc. are just tools to do that.

                                                • #78906
                                                  Susan David
                                                  Participant
                                                    • Allows Edits:
                                                    • Posts:279
                                                    @susandavid

                                                    No Achievements Yet!

                                                    @admin LOL Someone had to finally do it. When I’m teaching my group meetings I like to stress that it’s not about the camera or the paper you use it’s the individual behind the camera that takes the photograph that’s important. The camera, paper, etc. are just tools to do that.

                                                  • #57093
                                                    Rob Wood (Admin)
                                                    Keymaster
                                                      • https://instagram.com/lightstalking
                                                      • https://www.flickr.com/photos/lightstalking
                                                      • Allows Edits: Yes
                                                      • Posts:16097
                                                      @admin-2
                                                      • Photo of the Week Winner Icon
                                                      • Mobile Maestro Icon
                                                      • Contender Icon
                                                      • Socialite Icon
                                                      Allows Edits? Yes

                                                      Oh sure, but a good throw down feels so good every now and then! πŸ˜‰

                                                    • #78907
                                                      Rob Wood (Admin)
                                                      Keymaster
                                                        • https://instagram.com/lightstalking
                                                        • https://www.flickr.com/photos/lightstalking
                                                        • Allows Edits: Yes
                                                        • Posts:16097
                                                        @admin-2
                                                        • Photo of the Week Winner Icon
                                                        • Mobile Maestro Icon
                                                        • Contender Icon
                                                        • Socialite Icon
                                                        Allows Edits? Yes

                                                        Oh sure, but a good throw down feels so good every now and then! πŸ˜‰

                                                      • #57094
                                                        Susan David
                                                        Participant
                                                          • Allows Edits:
                                                          • Posts:279
                                                          @susandavid

                                                          No Achievements Yet!

                                                          It does feel good πŸ™‚

                                                        • #78908
                                                          Susan David
                                                          Participant
                                                            • Allows Edits:
                                                            • Posts:279
                                                            @susandavid

                                                            No Achievements Yet!

                                                            It does feel good πŸ™‚

                                                        Viewing 26 reply threads
                                                        • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

                                                        About Author